Atlee Hall and Kline & Specter secure important win for patients in Smith v. Kannarkatt
On October 29, 2026, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania issued a unanimous decision in Smith v. Kannarkatt, No. 17 MAP 2025, reaffirming a cornerstone of Pennsylvania medical malpractice law: when a doctor’s negligence increases the risk of harm to a patient, the question of whether that negligence caused the patient’s injury belongs to the jury. As a result, the Smith family’s case has been remanded to the York County Court of Common Pleas for a new trial.
Atlee Hall attorneys Thomas Hall and Jeff Gutkowski have represented the Smith family since the case began, through two jury trials in York County. When the defendants took the case to the Supreme Court, Atlee Hall turned to Kline & Specter’s appellate team to lead the appeal.
Charles Becker and Andra Laidacker of Kline & Specter briefed and argued the case before the Court. They are among the most respected appellate advocates in Pennsylvania and nationally, with a long record of protecting individuals’ rights. Bringing them in reflects our commitment to giving every client the strongest possible team at every stage of a case.
What Happened In The Lead Up to The Case
In March 2017, Tanya Smith was found to have an enlarged lymph node in her armpit. A pathologist reviewed the biopsy and reported metastatic adenocarcinoma “compatible with” breast origin. In the days that followed, a CT scan, PET scan, mammogram, and ultrasound all failed to find any primary breast tumor, and the CT and PET results listed lymphoma as a possible diagnosis.
Her oncologist had all of those results in hand. Even so, she did not go back to the pathologist to question the diagnosis, and she treated Mrs. Smith for breast cancer with chemotherapy and radiation for roughly a year. The chemotherapy did little, and the cancer spread.
In 2018, a new biopsy revealed the truth: Mrs. Smith had ALK-positive large B-cell lymphoma, a rare and aggressive cancer. A re-examination of the original 2017 tissue showed she had had lymphoma all along. By the time she began lymphoma-directed treatment, the disease had spread widely, and she had been weakened by a year of the wrong chemotherapy. She died in January 2019.
The Trial Court Took the Case Away From the Jury
At trial in York County, the family presented a standard-of-care expert who testified that a reasonable oncologist, faced with clinical and imaging findings that did not align with the pathology report, should have called the pathologist to request a closer look. Their causation expert, a lymphoma and bone marrow transplant specialist, testified that the 13-month delay in correct diagnosis and treatment deprived Mrs. Smith of a substantially better opportunity for a longer life. He explained that untreated lymphoma grows, mutates, and becomes harder to treat, and that transplants work best when performed early and with less disease.
The trial court nonetheless granted a compulsory nonsuit, ruling that the family had not proven causation. The Superior Court reversed and ordered a new trial. The defendants then appealed to the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court’s Holding
Writing for a unanimous Court, Justice Brobson affirmed the Superior Court and reaffirmed the “increased risk of harm” standard first adopted in Hamil v. Bashline (1978). Under that standard, a plaintiff makes out a prima facie case of causation by presenting expert testimony, to a reasonable degree of medical certainty, that the defendant’s negligence increased the risk of the harm the patient actually suffered. It is then up to the jury to weigh the evidence and decide whether that negligence was a substantial factor in causing the harm.
Key points from the decision:
- Plaintiffs do not have to prove what “would have happened.” The defense argued the family needed evidence that a call to the pathologist would have changed the diagnosis and the outcome. The Court rejected that argument, observing that it is impossible to know what would have happened had the oncologist made that call, and that this kind of uncertainty is exactly why the relaxed causation standard exists.
- More than one provider can be a cause. The defense tried to place all responsibility on the pathologist who made the original misdiagnosis. The Court held that whether the oncologist’s conduct was a substantial factor, alongside the pathologist’s conduct or the underlying disease, is a question for the jury.
- Survival statistics do not end the case. The defense stressed that Mrs. Smith lived about as long as the average patient with her cancer. The Court found that the family’s expert testimony was still enough to send the case to the jury, and that arguments about the weight and credibility of that testimony are for jurors, not for a judge on a motion for nonsuit.
- Experts do not need “magic words.” Courts look at the substance of the expert testimony as a whole.
The Court also distinguished Montgomery v. South Philadelphia Medical Group (Pa. Super. 1995), in which the plaintiff’s expert could only say it was “very possible” that a delay had increased the risk of harm. Here, by contrast, the family’s experts testified to a reasonable degree of medical certainty about both the breach of the standard of care and the increased risk.
Notably, the defense was supported by amicus briefs from the Hospital and Healthsystem Association of Pennsylvania, the American Medical Association and the Pennsylvania Medical Society. The Pennsylvania Association for Justice filed in support of the Smith family.
Why This Decision Matters
Many medical malpractice cases involve patients who were already seriously ill. In those cases, a negligent provider can almost always argue that the patient might have suffered the same outcome anyway. The Hamil standard ensures that a provider is not shielded from accountability simply because the consequences of negligence cannot be known with certainty.
Smith v. Kannarkatt confirms that this protection remains firmly in place. It also makes clear that each member of a patient’s care team has an independent responsibility to act when the clinical picture does not add up, and that an oncologist cannot simply defer to a pathology report that the rest of the medical evidence contradicts.
The case now returns to the York County Court of Common Pleas for a new trial, where a jury will decide whether the oncologist’s conduct was a substantial factor in Mrs. Smith’s harm.
About Atlee Hall
Atlee Hall represents individuals and families harmed by medical negligence and other serious injuries. If you believe you or a loved one has been harmed by a delayed or missed diagnosis, contact us for a free consultation.
The case is Smith v. Kannarkatt, No. 17 MAP 2025 (Pa. Oct. 29, 2026). Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
