Atlee Hall successfully arbitrated a case and secured a verdict on behalf of a client whose surgeon dismissed the warning signs of cauda equina syndrome, a surgical emergency, leaving her with permanent and life-altering injuries.

Our client underwent lumbar spine surgery to relieve years of back pain. In the days that followed, she developed the classic warning signs of cauda equina syndrome, including urinary retention, loss of sensation, and loss of bowel control. She repeatedly called and visited her surgeon to report these worsening symptoms.

Imaging results could not rule out nerve compression, yet her surgeon dismissed the findings and chose observation over emergency decompression surgery. By the time her condition was finally addressed, the damage was permanent. She now lives with lifelong bowel and bladder dysfunction, chronic pain, and a loss of sensation that has cost her the ability to work and to enjoy the relationships and activities she once had.

Why This Case Matters

Cauda equina syndrome is a recognized surgical emergency. The window for intervention is narrow, and the warning signs, urinary retention, loss of sensation, and loss of bowel control, are well established in medical literature. When a post-surgical patient reports these symptoms repeatedly, the standard of care requires urgent evaluation and, where nerve compression cannot be ruled out, emergency decompression.

This case raised significant questions about whether our client's surgeon took her repeated reports seriously. Imaging that could not rule out nerve compression was not an ambiguous result to be watched. It was a signal that demanded action. Choosing observation over emergency decompression, in the face of that evidence, allowed permanent nerve damage to set in.